Does Night Shift or night mode help you sleep?

In a 2021 trial of 167 young adults, Night Shift made no difference to sleep. Brightness and putting the phone down seem to matter more than screen colour.

Screens5 min readOcufuse team

New articles by email

One email a week.

Probably not much on its own. In a 2021 study of 167 young adults, using an iPhone with Night Shift on before bed led to the same sleep as using it with Night Shift off, and the same as not using a phone at all.

A common question goes like this: I keep Night Shift on every evening so my phone looks orange at bedtime, but I still lie awake after scrolling. Is the setting doing anything? The research so far suggests the colour of the screen is a smaller part of the picture than its brightness and what you're doing on it.

For the wider evidence on screens, sleep and tired eyes, see sleep, screens and tired eyes. Dark mode is a different setting, covered in is dark mode better for your eyes.

What Night Shift and night light settings actually do

Apple describes Night Shift as a setting that "automatically adjusts the colors of your display to the warmer end of the spectrum". By default it runs from sunset to sunrise, using your clock and location, and you can set your own schedule and how warm the colours go in Settings, then Display and Brightness, then Night Shift. Android phones and computers have similar settings, usually called Night Light or a blue light filter.

The idea behind them is reasonable. The American Academy of Ophthalmology (AAO) says blue light does affect the body's circadian rhythm, the natural wake and sleep cycle, and that too much of it late at night from a phone, tablet or computer can make it harder to get to sleep. Shifting the screen toward yellow cuts some of the blue.

Dark mode is something else. It changes apps to light text on a dark background. Some articles, including one from the AAO, use "night mode" to mean either setting, which is part of why the advice online gets muddled.

What the 2021 Night Shift study found

Researchers at Brigham Young University and Cincinnati Children's Hospital randomly assigned 167 iPhone users aged 18 to 24 to one of three groups for seven nights:

  • Phone use in the hour before bed with Night Shift on
  • Phone use in the hour before bed with Night Shift off
  • No phone use in the hour before bed

Everyone wore a wrist tracker that measured how long they took to fall asleep, how long they slept, how much of the night they were awake and how efficient their sleep was. Across the whole group, there were no significant differences between the three. One of the researchers put it plainly in the university's write-up: Night Shift wasn't better than using a phone without it, or even than using no phone at all.

When the team split people by how much they usually slept, a pattern showed up for those averaging about seven hours or more. In that group, the people who didn't use a phone before bed had the best sleep efficiency and spent less time awake during the night. Night Shift didn't close that gap. For people sleeping under about 6.8 hours, nothing made a difference, which the researchers put down to them being so short of sleep that they dropped off regardless.

Those subgroup results were exploratory, worked out after the main analysis, and the study only included university students. It's one study, but it's the closest thing to a direct test of the setting itself.

Brightness may matter more than colour

An earlier lab study from the Lighting Research Center at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute looked at melatonin, the hormone that rises in the evening before sleep. People looked at iPads with Night Shift set to its warmest and coolest settings. Melatonin suppression didn't differ significantly between the two, and the authors concluded that changing a screen's colour without changing its brightness may not be enough to prevent the effect.

The 2021 team also pointed to something colour can't touch: what you're doing. Texting, scrolling and reading the news keep your mind busy whatever shade the screen is.

Night Shift or Night Light
  • Warms the colour of the screen
  • Leaves brightness as it is
  • No difference to sleep in the 2021 study
Lower brightness
  • Less light reaching your eyes overall
  • Less glare against a dark room
  • Easy to pair with Night Shift
Phone down earlier
  • No screen light at all
  • Less to keep your mind busy
  • Best sleep quality in the 2021 subgroup
What each habit changes, in general terms. None of these is a sleep treatment.

How long before bed to put the phone down

There's no single agreed number. One AAO article suggests limiting screen time in the one to two hours before bed. Another quotes an ophthalmologist who suggests two to three hours. The study above only tested the last hour. If those numbers feel out of reach, starting with 30 minutes and charging the phone across the room is a realistic first step for a lot of people.

A simple evening setup
  • Schedule Night Shift or Night Light to come on automatically
  • Turn brightness down too, rather than relying on colour alone
  • Pick a time to stop scrolling and set a reminder for it
  • Charge the phone out of reach of the bed
  • Swap the last stretch of the evening for something without a screen

Night Shift does have one thing going for it. The AAO notes that a very bright screen in a dark room may cause digital eye strain, and a warmer, dimmer screen is simply more comfortable for many people at night. There's no known harm in leaving it on. The AAO is also clear that blue light from screens doesn't damage the eye.

When to talk to someone

If you've changed your evening screen habits and still sleep badly most nights, a GP or doctor is the right person to talk to about sleep. If your eyes are regularly sore, dry or tired after evenings on a screen, mention it at your next eye test, or book a visit with an eye care professional sooner if it's getting in the way of your day.

Read more by topic

Common questions

Does Night Shift help you fall asleep faster?

In a 2021 study of 167 adults aged 18 to 24, time to fall asleep didn't differ between people using Night Shift, people using their phone without it and people who didn't use a phone in the hour before bed.

Is Night Shift the same as dark mode?

No. Night Shift warms the colours of the whole display toward the yellow and orange end. Dark mode switches apps to light text on a dark background. Some articles use "night mode" for both.

How long before bed should I stop using screens?

Advice varies. One American Academy of Ophthalmology article suggests limiting screen time in the one to two hours before bed, and another quotes an ophthalmologist suggesting two to three hours.

Is it still worth turning Night Shift on?

Many people find a warmer, dimmer screen more comfortable in a dark room, and there's no known harm. Just don't count on it alone to change how you sleep.

Sources

  1. Duraccio KM et al., Sleep Health, 2021: Does iPhone Night Shift mitigate negative effects of smartphone use on sleep outcomes in emerging adults?
  2. Brigham Young University News (2021): Is Night Shift really helping you sleep better?
  3. Nagare R et al., Lighting Research and Technology, 2019: Does the iPad Night Shift mode reduce melatonin suppression?
  4. Apple Support: Use Night Shift on your iPhone, iPad and iPod touch
  5. American Academy of Ophthalmology: Should you use night mode to reduce blue light?
  6. American Academy of Ophthalmology: Should you be worried about blue light?

End of article

New articles by email

One email a week with the articles we published that week.

What to do next

Read next

Try the tool

Eye symptom journal

Log how your eyes feel, with screen time, sleep and drops, in a few taps a day. Free in the Ocufuse web app.

Open the eye symptom journal
Ocufuse Plus

Try Ocufuse Plus free for 7 days

  • Every eye game
  • Your full history
  • Doctor Brief
  1. TodayPlus opens straight away. No charge today.
  2. Any time before Cancel from Settings in the app, and you won't be charged.
  3. Your plan starts at $64.99 a year, unless you cancelled.
Start my 7-day free trial

Then $64.99 a year. Cancel anytime.

7-day free trial for first-time subscribers, then $64.99 a year. A card is needed to start. Renews automatically each year until you cancel. Cancel anytime in Settings, or before the trial ends to pay nothing. Prices in US dollars, plus tax where applicable.

Secure checkout with Stripe

Compare all plans